Showing posts with label dan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dan. Show all posts

Tuesday, 8 December 2020

REVERSE PROFILES IN RECREATIONAL DIVING

Many of us, reading our Open Water Diver manuals (including PADI and CMAS) have been instructed and warned about the danger of diving s.c. reverse profiles.

Briefly explained, reverse profiles occur when, within a single dive, the latter portion of the dive is deeper than the earlier portion or, in the case of repetitive dives, the repeat dive is deeper than the earlier one.

 

Although the rule against reverse dive profiles has been (and apparently still is) widely accepted and taught by major recreational diving agencies, it is not clear where did this rule came from and which was the scientific motivation behind it. Sure thing, historically this limitation could be explained by the use of dive plan tables and electronic dive planner that were only in the condition of calculating bottom time and nitrogen loading only based on the maximum depth and time figures.

With this in mind, in the year 1999 the Smithsonian Institution and AAUS (American Academy of Underwater Sciences) called a Workshop with the purpose of investigating, among others,  if there is any physiological basis (read “DCS incidence”) for the rule against reverse profiles ( Reverse Dive Profiles Workshop, Washington DC, October 29 and 30, 1999).

The results of this study, that considered modern bubble decompression models, were:

  • Historically neither the U.S. Navy nor the commercial sector have prohibited reverse dive profiles. 

  • Reverse dive profiles are being performed in recreational, scientific, commercial, and military diving. 

  • The prohibition of reverse dive profiles by recreational training organizations cannot be traced to any 
definite diving experience that indicates an increased risk of DCS. 

  • No convincing evidence was presented that reverse dive profiles within the no-decompression limits 
lead to a measurable increase in the risk of DCS.


Within this research, the possible increase of DCS cases possibly connected to reverse profiles was explained with the fact that very often reverse profiles are associated to repetitive dives on multiple days activity and connected nitrogen exposure.  

The conclusion of the study was that if diving within no decompression limits and less than 40 meters, and within a maximum depth difference of 12 meters, the current evidence does not show any demonstrable increase in risk of DCS.

With this in mind, and with the generic commercial spread of dive computers with algorithms capable of adequately calculate bottom time and residual nitrogen loading for reverse profiles, today the only reason for avoiding reverse profiles in recreational diving seems to be purely based on the necessity of maximizing the dive duration.

In fact, even if apparently not relevant for DCS, reverse profiles  still significantly reduce the available bottom time, and this is for sure a valid reason for avoiding them when possible: for sure, when we are on holiday, we want to maximize our fun and to stay below water as long as we can!

One last consideration: the position of the Smithsonian Institution and AAUS is not globally shared and there have been more recent studies showing different results, even though based on animal experiments (The relative safety of forward and reverse diving profiles. S. McInnes, C. Edmonds, M. Bennett, UHM 2005: VOL 32, ISSUE #6).

Nonetheless, the results of the 1999 Workshop are still widely accepted, among others, also by Divers Alert Network (DAN).

I share this article based on my best knowledge and research on public documentation as well as literature in my possession. If any of you fellow divers out there, especially tech divers, do have any further information or authoritative source, I would be happy to further investigate and discuss with you!

 

 

Thursday, 23 April 2020

DAN & A.DI.SUB RELEASE 10 RECCOMENDATIONS ON COVID-19 RISK MITIGATION FOR SCUBA OPERATORS

Waiting for the reopening of SCUBA Diving activities in Italy, DAN in cooperation with A.Di.Sub, releases a document with 10 reccomentation on the correct risk mitigation protocols for SCUBA Diving Operators: click here or on the image below to read and download the full documentation (in Italian).


https://www.daneurope.org/readarticle?p_p_id=web_content_reading&p_p_lifecycle=0&p_p_mode=view&p_p_col_id=column-1&p_p_col_count=1&p_r_p_-1523133153_groupId=10103&p_r_p_-1523133153_articleId=14155950&p_r_p_-1523133153_articleVersion=1.0&p_r_p_-1523133153_articleType=General+Web+Content&p_r_p_-1523133153_commaCategories=NEWS&p_r_p_-1523133153_commaTags=&p_r_p_-1523133153_templateId=5993844
 




Friday, 17 April 2020

DIVING AND SMOKING

I know what you are thinking now: all diving professionals are smokers...


Some weeks ago, sitting in a restaurant with friends, I was listening to a discussion about how smoking impacts the human physiology with particular focus on diving activity. They all obviously agreed that smoking is bad and must be avoided in general, but nobody really was in the condition of explaining why divers in particular shall not smoke and what are the consequences of smoking in combination with diving.

I am not a physician myself so I am not going to arrange a self made text with the risk of sharing incorrect contents. By the way, I found this two articles on the website of DAN Asia Pacific (www.danap.org), which I think can give us a good and brief basic scientific overview about the consequences of smoking and diving (click on the title to read the full article):



So if we really can not resist and keep smoking also after reading this articles, please try to follow some simple rules at least:

  1. on the boat, smoke only in designated smoking areas;
  2. smoke down-wind;
  3. dispose properly of cigarette butts.

I am happy to read other scientific information or documentation, if you have any to share!




DCS RISK FACTORS AND LIFESTYLE

In one of the first articles on my blog we discussed about smoking and its consequences on scuba diving ( https://scubadivinggoodpractices.b...